We've long had the belief at Cards Diaspora that awards for individual players aren't worth having arguments about.
Good on Molina and Carpenter and any other Cardinal that gets an award or consideration for one. Generally that means they helped contribute to wins during gameplay.
But getting worked up over them? We'll pass. We used to care (a whole bunch), but that turned out to be a fool's errand.
That being said... I guess I'd rather have the STL contingent of voters be homers, if nothing more than to PO division rivals. So good work Commish. Carp over McCutcheon indeed.